The Rolex Explorer II is one of the most practical and underrated Rolex sports watches ever made. It has a fixed 24-hour bezel, a bold 24-hour hand, a date function, strong adventure heritage and a personality that feels more rugged than flashy. While the Submariner, Daytona and GMT-Master II often receive more attention, the Explorer II has built a loyal following among collectors who appreciate serious tool-watch design.
But if you are shopping for one, the important question is simple: which are the best Rolex Explorer II references to buy?
The answer depends on your collecting goals. Some buyers want the original Explorer II reference 1655 because of its vintage orange-hand charm. Others prefer the transitional 16550, the long-running 16570, the larger anniversary-inspired 216570 or the current 226570. Some buyers want the white Polar dial, while others prefer the black dial for understated daily wear.
This guide breaks down the best Rolex Explorer II references, including vintage, neo-vintage, discontinued modern and current-production models. We will cover what makes each reference special, who each model is best for, which versions are most collectible, and what to check before buying.
At The Luxury Watch Home, we help collectors and first-time buyers shop authentic luxury watches with confidence. You can browse our luxury watches for sale, view our new arrivals, explore pre-owned luxury watches, shop unworn luxury watches, or request help to source a specific Rolex Explorer II.
Table of Contents
- Best Rolex Explorer II References: Quick Answer
- How to Choose the Right Rolex Explorer II Reference
- Rolex Explorer II 1655: The Original Orange-Hand Explorer II
- Rolex Explorer II 16550: The Transitional Collector Reference
- Rolex Explorer II 16570: The Best Classic Daily-Wear Explorer II
- Rolex Explorer II 216570: The 42mm Anniversary-Era Explorer II
- Rolex Explorer II 226570: The Best Current Explorer II
- Polar vs Black Dial Explorer II References
- Best Vintage Explorer II Reference
- Best Neo-Vintage Explorer II Reference
- Best Modern Explorer II Reference
- Best Explorer II Reference by Buyer Type
- Which Explorer II References Hold Value Best?
- Condition, Originality and Box and Papers
- Pre-Owned vs Unworn Rolex Explorer II
- Common Mistakes When Buying Explorer II References
- Where to Buy an Authentic Rolex Explorer II Safely
- Frequently Asked Questions
Best Rolex Explorer II References: Quick Answer
If you want the quick answer, these are the best Rolex Explorer II references to know:
| Reference | Era | Best For |
|---|---|---|
| 1655 | Vintage | Original Explorer II collectors and orange-hand vintage lovers |
| 16550 | Transitional | Collectors who want a short-production Explorer II with transitional details |
| 16570 | Neo-vintage / classic modern | Best classic daily-wear Explorer II and strongest 40mm option |
| 216570 | Discontinued modern | Best larger 42mm Explorer II with anniversary-era design |
| 226570 | Current modern | Best current-generation Explorer II with calibre 3285 |
For most buyers, the Explorer II 16570 and Explorer II 226570 are the easiest recommendations. The 16570 is excellent if you want a 40mm Explorer II with classic proportions, while the 226570 is the best choice if you want the current-generation 42mm model.
For collectors, the 1655 is the original and most historically important Explorer II. The 16550 is the transitional reference with serious collector interest. The 216570 is the discontinued 42mm generation that brought back the orange-hand personality in a modern case.
How to Choose the Right Rolex Explorer II Reference
The best Rolex Explorer II reference depends on what kind of buyer you are. The Explorer II has changed over time, but the core idea has remained consistent: a rugged Rolex sports watch with a 24-hour display and adventure-ready identity.
Before choosing a reference, ask yourself:
- Do I want vintage, neo-vintage, discontinued modern or current production?
- Do I prefer a 40mm or 42mm case?
- Do I want a white Polar dial or black dial?
- Am I buying for daily wear, collecting or long-term value?
- Do I want the original orange-hand reference?
- Do I prefer modern movement technology?
- Is box and papers important to me?
- How much wrist presence do I want?
The Explorer II is especially interesting because it offers a range of personalities. The 1655 feels vintage and unusual. The 16570 feels compact and highly wearable. The 216570 feels bold and modern. The 226570 feels like the most refined current version.
The right reference is not always the most expensive one. It is the one that fits your wrist, budget, style and ownership goals.
Rolex Explorer II 1655: The Original Orange-Hand Explorer II
The Rolex Explorer II reference 1655 is the original Explorer II and one of the most important references in the model’s history. It introduced the fixed 24-hour bezel and the bold orange 24-hour hand that would later become a major part of the Explorer II identity.
The 1655 is very different from modern Explorer II watches. It has a vintage case feel, a more unusual dial layout and a strong tool-watch personality. It was not designed to be flashy. It was designed for explorers who needed a clear 24-hour reference in environments where day and night could become difficult to distinguish.
Why the Explorer II 1655 matters
- Original Rolex Explorer II reference
- Iconic orange 24-hour hand
- Fixed 24-hour bezel
- Strong vintage tool-watch personality
- Highly collectible among Explorer II enthusiasts
- Important foundation for all later Explorer II models
Who should buy the Explorer II 1655?
The Explorer II 1655 is best for serious vintage Rolex collectors. It is not usually the easiest Explorer II to buy, because originality, dial condition, bezel condition, case shape, bracelet correctness and service history are very important.
If you want the most historically important Explorer II and are comfortable buying carefully, the 1655 is the reference that started the story.
Rolex Explorer II 16550: The Transitional Collector Reference
The Rolex Explorer II reference 16550 is one of the most interesting Explorer II references because it is a transitional model. It moved the Explorer II toward the more modern design language many buyers recognize today while retaining strong collector character.
The 16550 introduced important changes compared with the 1655, including a more modern dial layout and a case profile that feels closer to later Explorer II references. It is also known among collectors for certain white dial examples that aged into a cream tone, creating additional collector interest.
Why the Explorer II 16550 is special
- Important transitional Explorer II reference
- Shorter production era than many later models
- More modern dial layout than the 1655
- Available in white and black dial configurations
- Cream dial examples can attract collector interest
- Strong bridge between vintage and neo-vintage Explorer II design
Who should buy the Explorer II 16550?
The 16550 is best for collectors who want something more unusual than a 16570 but more wearable than a 1655. It is especially appealing if you appreciate transitional Rolex references and collector details.
When buying a 16550, condition and dial originality are very important. White dial examples should be examined carefully, especially when cream patina or dial aging is involved.
Rolex Explorer II 16570: The Best Classic Daily-Wear Explorer II
The Rolex Explorer II reference 16570 is one of the best Explorer II references for everyday wear. It offers a 40mm case, white or black dial options, a fixed 24-hour bezel and a more compact feel than the later 42mm models.
For many buyers, the 16570 is the sweet spot. It is modern enough to wear regularly, old enough to have character, and more compact than the current Explorer II. It is also one of the most popular pre-owned Explorer II references.
Why the Explorer II 16570 is a strong buy
- 40mm case size
- White Polar and black dial options
- More compact than modern 42mm Explorer II models
- Excellent daily wearability
- Strong pre-owned market availability
- Classic Explorer II proportions
- Good balance of value, function and collectability
White Polar 16570 vs black dial 16570
The white Polar 16570 is ideal if you want the most distinctive Explorer II look. The black dial 16570 is better if you want a more traditional and understated Rolex sports watch.
Who should buy the Explorer II 16570?
The 16570 is best for buyers who want a classic 40mm Explorer II that can be worn daily. It is especially attractive for people who find the current 42mm Explorer II too large.
For many collectors and first-time Explorer II buyers, the 16570 is one of the smartest references to consider.
Rolex Explorer II 216570: The 42mm Anniversary-Era Explorer II
The Rolex Explorer II reference 216570 is the discontinued modern Explorer II that introduced a larger 42mm case. It also brought back the bold orange 24-hour hand, creating a clear visual connection to the original 1655.
The 216570 feels much larger and more modern than the 16570. It is a strong choice for buyers who want the Explorer II to have more wrist presence and a more contemporary tool-watch feel.
Why the Explorer II 216570 is worth considering
- Discontinued modern Explorer II reference
- 42mm case size
- Bold orange 24-hour hand
- White Polar or black dial options
- Strong adventure-watch personality
- More wrist presence than the 16570
- Attractive pre-owned option for modern buyers
Who should buy the Explorer II 216570?
The 216570 is best for buyers who want a modern 42mm Explorer II but prefer a discontinued reference rather than the current 226570. It is especially strong for larger wrists and buyers who want a bolder Explorer II than the 16570.
If you want modern size, strong tool-watch presence and pre-owned market value, the 216570 is a very good Explorer II reference to consider.
Rolex Explorer II 226570: The Best Current Explorer II
The Rolex Explorer II reference 226570 is the current-generation Explorer II. It continues the 42mm design, fixed 24-hour bezel, white and black dial options, orange 24-hour hand and rugged Explorer II identity.
The 226570 is powered by Rolex calibre 3285 and represents the most refined modern Explorer II ownership experience. It is the best choice for buyers who want the current reference, current movement generation and a clean modern watch.
Why the Explorer II 226570 is a strong buy
- Current-generation Explorer II
- 42mm Oystersteel case
- Calibre 3285
- White Polar and black dial options
- Fixed 24-hour bezel
- 100-metre water resistance
- Modern Rolex sports-watch construction
- Best choice for unworn current Explorer II buyers
Who should buy the Explorer II 226570?
The 226570 is best for buyers who want the newest Explorer II reference. Choose the white Polar dial if you want the most distinctive Explorer II look. Choose the black dial if you want the same function in a more understated package.
For most buyers who want a current Rolex Explorer II, the 226570 is the reference to buy.
Polar vs Black Dial Explorer II References
Every major modern Explorer II reference is strongly shaped by dial choice. The white Polar dial and black dial versions feel very different even when they share the same case and movement generation.
Why buyers choose the Polar Explorer II
- Distinctive white dial
- Strong contrast and legibility
- Collector nickname recognition
- Adventure-focused personality
- Feels different from many black dial Rolex sports watches
- Often considered the most iconic Explorer II look
Why buyers choose the black dial Explorer II
- More understated appearance
- Traditional Rolex sports-watch feel
- Easy to wear daily
- Less visually bright
- Works well with darker wardrobes
- Often feels more subtle on the wrist
For collectability and Explorer II identity, many buyers prefer the Polar dial. For everyday discretion and classic tool-watch style, the black dial is excellent.
The best choice depends on your style. Buy the dial you will enjoy wearing, not only the one receiving more attention online.
Best Vintage Explorer II Reference
The best vintage Explorer II reference is the 1655. It is the original Explorer II and the most historically important reference in the model family.
The 1655 has a unique appearance that separates it from later Explorer II watches. Its orange 24-hour hand, vintage dial design and fixed bezel give it a collector personality that modern references cannot fully replicate.
Why the 1655 is the best vintage Explorer II
- Original Explorer II reference
- Most historically important model
- Vintage orange-hand identity
- Strong collector demand
- Distinctive dial and bezel design
- Foundation of the Explorer II family
The 1655 is best for serious collectors, not casual buyers. It should be purchased only after careful authentication and review of originality.
Best Neo-Vintage Explorer II Reference
The best neo-vintage Explorer II reference is the 16570. It offers classic 40mm proportions, practical wearability, white and black dial options, and strong Explorer II identity without the complexity or price level of earlier vintage references.
The 16570 is one of the most wearable Explorer II models ever made. It is slim enough for daily wear, rugged enough to feel like a true tool watch, and distinctive enough to stand apart from other Rolex sports watches.
Why the 16570 is the best neo-vintage Explorer II
- 40mm case size
- Excellent daily wearability
- White Polar and black dial options
- Strong pre-owned availability
- More compact than later 42mm references
- Great balance of value and collectability
The 16570 is a strong choice for buyers who want a practical Explorer II with character. It is also an excellent alternative for buyers who find the current 42mm Explorer II too large.
Best Modern Explorer II Reference
The best modern Explorer II reference depends on whether you want discontinued modern or current production.
The 216570 is the best discontinued modern Explorer II. It has the larger 42mm case, bold orange 24-hour hand and strong modern tool-watch feel. It is excellent for buyers who want a pre-owned modern Explorer II with more wrist presence.
The 226570 is the best current Explorer II. It offers the newest generation, calibre 3285 and current Rolex construction. It is ideal for buyers who want an unworn or current-production Explorer II experience.
| Modern Reference | Best For | Why |
|---|---|---|
| 216570 | Discontinued modern buyers | 42mm case, orange hand, strong pre-owned value appeal |
| 226570 | Current-generation buyers | Calibre 3285, current reference, refined modern construction |
Choose the 216570 if you want a discontinued 42mm Explorer II. Choose the 226570 if you want the current model.
Best Explorer II Reference by Buyer Type
Different Explorer II references fit different buyers. Here is a practical breakdown.
Best Explorer II for vintage collectors
Choose the Explorer II 1655. It is the original and most historically important reference.
Best Explorer II for transitional collectors
Choose the Explorer II 16550. It is a short-production transitional reference with strong collector interest.
Best Explorer II for daily wear
Choose the Explorer II 16570. Its 40mm case makes it one of the easiest Explorer II references to wear daily.
Best Explorer II for larger wrists
Choose the Explorer II 216570 or 226570. Both offer a 42mm case with stronger wrist presence.
Best Explorer II for current-generation buyers
Choose the Explorer II 226570. It is the current reference and the most modern Explorer II option.
Best Explorer II for white dial Rolex lovers
Choose a Polar dial Explorer II, especially the 16570, 216570 or 226570 depending on your preferred size and era.
Best Explorer II for understated buyers
Choose a black dial Explorer II. It keeps the rugged function while wearing more quietly.
Best Explorer II for value-focused buyers
Compare the 16570 and 216570. Both can offer strong pre-owned value depending on condition and completeness.
Which Explorer II References Hold Value Best?
Rolex Explorer II references can hold value well when purchased correctly, especially clean examples with strong condition, original parts, box and papers, and desirable dial configurations.
Explorer II references with strong value appeal often include:
- 1655 for vintage collector importance
- 16550 for transitional rarity and dial interest
- 16570 for classic 40mm wearability
- 216570 for discontinued 42mm modern appeal
- 226570 for current-generation demand
- Polar dial examples across several generations
- Complete sets in excellent condition
Value depends on many factors:
- Reference number
- Dial color
- Condition
- Originality
- Box and papers
- Service history
- Case polishing
- Bracelet condition
- Market demand
- Purchase price
The Explorer II may not always receive the same hype as the GMT-Master II or Daytona, but that can make it attractive to buyers who want practical Rolex sports-watch value without chasing the loudest market trend.
Condition, Originality and Box and Papers
Condition is extremely important when buying any Rolex Explorer II. Because the model is often worn as a practical sports watch, pre-owned examples can show wear on the case, bezel, bracelet and clasp.
Before buying, check:
- Case condition
- Bezel condition
- Bracelet condition
- Dial originality
- Hand condition
- Crystal condition
- Movement service history
- Polishing history
- Correct reference details
- Box and papers
For vintage references like the 1655, originality is especially important. Dial, hands, bezel, bracelet and case condition should be reviewed carefully. For modern references like 216570 and 226570, box and papers can improve buyer confidence and resale appeal.
You can learn more about our review standards through our Watch Inspection Process.
Pre-Owned vs Unworn Rolex Explorer II
The best way to buy a Rolex Explorer II depends on whether you want a current model, discontinued reference or vintage watch.
Buying a pre-owned Rolex Explorer II
A pre-owned Explorer II gives buyers access to discontinued references such as 16570 and 216570, as well as vintage and transitional references like 1655 and 16550. Pre-owned buying can also offer strong value when condition and pricing are attractive.
You can explore available watches through our pre-owned luxury watches page.
Buying an unworn Rolex Explorer II
An unworn Explorer II is ideal if you want a pristine current-generation 226570. This is a strong choice for buyers who want the newest reference in clean condition, whether white Polar dial or black dial.
You can browse current options through our unworn luxury watches page.
Sourcing a specific Explorer II reference
If you want a specific Explorer II reference, dial, year, condition or complete set, sourcing may be the best route. This is especially useful for vintage 1655 examples, cream dial 16550 examples, clean full-set 16570 watches or current 226570 models.
Request help through our Source a Luxury Watch page.
Common Mistakes When Buying Explorer II References
The Explorer II is practical and rugged, but buyers still need to be careful. Avoid these common mistakes before purchasing.
1. Choosing only based on dial color
Polar and black dial Explorer II models wear very differently, but reference, condition and price matter just as much as dial color.
2. Ignoring case size
The 16570 is 40mm, while the 216570 and 226570 are 42mm. That size difference is very noticeable on the wrist.
3. Buying vintage without expert review
The 1655 and 16550 require careful authentication. Dial originality, bezel condition, case shape and correct parts are very important.
4. Assuming the newest model is always best
The 226570 is the current reference, but many buyers may prefer the proportions of the 16570 or the discontinued character of the 216570.
5. Overlooking the black dial
The Polar dial is famous, but the black dial Explorer II can be the better daily-wear choice for many buyers.
6. Forgetting box and papers
Complete sets can improve buyer confidence and resale appeal, especially for modern references.
7. Buying from an unknown seller
Rolex sports watches are valuable and commonly copied. Authentication, condition review and seller trust are essential.
Where to Buy an Authentic Rolex Explorer II Safely
Because the Rolex Explorer II is valuable and desirable, authenticity and condition should come first. A strong Explorer II purchase should be transparent, inspected and supported by a trusted luxury watch dealer.
Before buying, ask:
- Is the watch guaranteed authentic?
- Has the watch been inspected?
- Is the reference clearly listed?
- Is the dial color correctly described?
- Is the bezel correct for the model?
- Does the watch include box and papers?
- Is the condition accurately described?
- Is service history available?
- Are secure payment methods available?
- Is shipping insured?
- Is warranty support included?
At The Luxury Watch Home, we help buyers shop with confidence. You can review our Authenticity Guarantee, learn more about our Watch Inspection Process, view our Luxury Watch Warranty, and read about our Secure Payment Methods.
We also provide secure delivery information through our Luxury Watch Shipping & Delivery page.
Ready to find your Explorer II? Browse our luxury watches for sale, view our new arrivals, explore pre-owned luxury watches, shop unworn luxury watches, or contact us to source a Rolex Explorer II.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best Rolex Explorer II reference?
For most buyers, the best Rolex Explorer II references are the 16570 and 226570. The 16570 is excellent for classic 40mm daily wear, while the 226570 is the best current-generation Explorer II.
What is the original Rolex Explorer II reference?
The original Rolex Explorer II reference is the 1655. It is known for its vintage tool-watch design and bold orange 24-hour hand.
Is the Rolex Explorer II 16570 worth buying?
Yes. The Explorer II 16570 is worth buying if you want a classic 40mm Explorer II with strong daily wearability and pre-owned market appeal.
Is the Rolex Explorer II 226570 worth buying?
Yes. The Explorer II 226570 is worth buying if you want the current-generation Explorer II with a 42mm case, calibre 3285 and white or black dial options.
Which is better, Explorer II 16570 or 226570?
The 16570 is better if you want a more compact 40mm Explorer II. The 226570 is better if you want the current 42mm Explorer II with modern movement technology.
Which Explorer II is best for larger wrists?
The 216570 and 226570 are best for larger wrists because they have 42mm cases and stronger wrist presence.
Which Explorer II is best for smaller wrists?
The 16570 is usually better for smaller or medium wrists because it has a 40mm case and wears more compactly than the 42mm models.
Is the Polar Explorer II more collectible than the black dial?
The Polar Explorer II often has stronger collector identity because of its distinctive white dial and nickname. However, black dial Explorer II models are also desirable and can be better for understated daily wear.
Should I buy a pre-owned Rolex Explorer II?
A pre-owned Rolex Explorer II can be a smart purchase when it is authentic, well-preserved, fairly priced and properly inspected. Pre-owned buying also gives access to discontinued references like 16570 and 216570.
Where can I buy an authentic Rolex Explorer II online?
You can browse authentic luxury watches at The Luxury Watch Home. We offer pre-owned watches, unworn watches, new arrivals, secure payment information, warranty support and sourcing assistance for specific Rolex Explorer II models.
Final Thoughts: Best Rolex Explorer II References
The best Rolex Explorer II references each offer a different kind of appeal. The 1655 is the original and most historically important Explorer II. The 16550 is the transitional collector reference. The 16570 is the best classic daily-wear Explorer II. The 216570 is the bold discontinued 42mm modern reference. The 226570 is the best current-generation Explorer II.
For most buyers, the 16570 and 226570 are the strongest starting points. Choose the 16570 if you want a compact 40mm case and classic proportions. Choose the 226570 if you want the current model with modern Rolex movement technology and a larger 42mm case.
For collectors, the 1655 and 16550 deserve serious attention, but they require careful authentication and condition review. For buyers who want pre-owned value and modern wrist presence, the 216570 is also an excellent choice.
The smartest Explorer II purchase is not only about the reference number. It is about condition, originality, dial preference, box and papers, service history, wrist fit and seller trust.
Ready to find your Rolex Explorer II? Browse our luxury watches for sale, explore pre-owned luxury watches, shop unworn luxury watches, or contact our team to source a Rolex Explorer II in your preferred reference, dial, condition and complete set.
At The Luxury Watch Home, every timepiece is selected with care, inspected for confidence, and offered to help collectors choose authentic luxury watches with trust.
Suggested Image Alt Texts
- Best Rolex Explorer II references displayed on a luxury adventure collector desk
- Rolex Explorer II 1655 original orange hand reference buying guide
- Rolex Explorer II 16550 transitional collector reference
- Rolex Explorer II 16570 Polar dial pre-owned buying guide
- Rolex Explorer II 216570 discontinued 42mm model buying guide
- Rolex Explorer II 226570 current-generation Polar and black dial models
- Polar Explorer II vs black dial Explorer II reference comparison
- Pre-owned Rolex Explorer II inspected by luxury watch dealer
- Authentic Rolex Explorer II with box and papers before purchase
Suggested CTA Button Texts
- Shop Rolex Explorer II Watches
- Browse Luxury Watches
- View New Arrivals
- Shop Pre-Owned Watches
- Shop Unworn Watches
- Source a Rolex Explorer II
- Learn About Our Authenticity Guarantee
- Review Our Inspection Process